Puerto Rican Polvorones (Shortbread Cookies)

Polvorones or Mantecaditos are some of my favorite memories from growing up in Puerto Rico. They're our version of traditional Spanish shortbread cookies. Delicate, buttery, and mildly sweet, these jam or sprinkle-decorated cookies melt in your mouth, crumbling with each bite. Although these cookies are available at many stores, the BEST ones are homemade.

These polvorones cookies are trendy around Christmas and other festive Puerto Rican holiday treats like tembleque and coquito. Are you planning a Puerto Rican Holiday celebration? Don't forget to add Pernil, Arroz con Gandules, Pastelon, and Empanadillas to your menu.

Are you interested in more dessert ideas for the holidays? Check out my Bread Pudding recipe. The bread is soaked in the custard, creating a velvety, dense, homogenous texture. Puerto Rican Hojaldre: Do not let the name fool you; this is a delicious spice cake where cinnamon, cloves, and nutmeg are the stars of the show. Rice Pudding, another delightful dessert full of spice and warmth, is great for cozy winter evenings. Limbers de Coco, Puerto Rican Ice Pops or Creamy Pistachio LImbers are creamy and delicious , a must have on hot summer days. Or try Tropical Carrot Cake with Banana and Coconut. This carrot cake is moist by the pineapple and banana, the coconut enhances the tropical flavors and the citrus cream cheese frosting brings balance to the flavors.

What are Polvorones?

The name polvorones derives from the word "Polvo," meaning dust, playing on the idea that the cookie crumbles into dust as you bite into it. Traditionally in Spain, these shortbread cookies are made with almonds and typically dusted with powdered sugar, which adds to the name of "polvo"-rones. However, in Puerto Rico, we decorate these cookies with color sprinkles, guava paste, or, my favorite, Maracchino Cherries.

Why you will love this recipe?

• Simple Ingredients, Big Reward: With just a few simple ingredients, polvorones cookies are easy to make, yet they deliver a rich and satisfying flavor. They are perfect for beginner bakers or those who want to make something extraordinary without needing complex techniques.
• Creative Variations: Once you know the basics, polvorones are highly customizable. You can experiment with flavors like coconut, cinnamon, and lemon zest or even add colorful sprinkles or sugar coatings, making them delicious and visually appealing.
• Connection to Tradition: Polvorones are deeply rooted in Hispanic culture, so learning to make them is a way to connect with heritage and honor family traditions, especially if they hold sentimental value or are part of cherished holiday memories.
• Gift-Worthy: Homemade polvorones make thoughtful gifts, especially when packaged in a nice box or bag. They're an ideal treat to share with friends and family, symbolizing warmth and care.

Ingredient Notes

• Flour: Flour forms the structure of the polvorón. There is no need for specialty flour; good-ol' all-purpose flour does the trick. Flour provides the right amount of gluten to create a cohesive yet crumbly cookie.
• Fat: A combination of butter and lard is vital to the tender, crumbly texture of polvorones. This high-fat content prevents too much gluten development, keeping the cookie light and melt-in-the-mouth soft.
• Sugar: Sugar also adds to the crispiness of the cookie. Since not all the sugar crystals dissolve during baking, they add a bit of crunch to the polvorones.

See my recipe card below for a complete list of the ingredients with measurements.

• Never buy your lard from the shelf of an aisle in a major grocer. These shelf-stable products tend to be hydrogenated and linked to trans fats, which we want to avoid.
• Please find a local farmer who renders fat from his/her pigs. Not only will you get a better, fresher product, but you will also be supporting your local community. I buy my lard from a reputable organic farm a few miles from home. The lard is rendered and canned in a mason jar at the farm and kept under refrigeration.
• Prevention has a great article on the use of lard and its health benefits.

Variations and Substitutions

• Alternate Flours: My Keto-inspired polvorones are made with a combination of almond and coconut flours, which add a great deal of flavor to these cookies. If you are not following a keto lifestyle, only substitute the regular flour for the alternate.
• Toasting the flour: Toasting the flour adds warmth and nutty flavors and contributes to the signature sandy texture. Toasted flour also helps the polvorones crumble delicately when eaten.
• Alternate Fats: Experiment with using different fats to make these cookies. Coconut oil can replace butter in a 1:1 ratio. Make sure you use solid-state coconut oil, but beware that it will melt at 75℉ or warmer. I suggest whipping the solid coconut oil lightly before adding the sugar to soften the oil. Then add sugar. If it begins to melt, place it in the fridge for a few minutes before continuing.

How to make Puerto Rican Polvorones

Here are the step-by-step instructions on how to make polvorones.

Leave butter on the counter and let it come to room temperature. Preheat the oven to 350℉. Place the oven rack in the center of the oven.

1. In a bowl, cream butter and vegetable shortening. Then add sugar and cream until incorporated.

2. Add almond extract

3. Add flour

4. When done, the dough will have a sandy consistency. However, it will hold its shape when rolled into a ball.

5. With a small scoop or spoon, portion small amounts and roll with your hand to make a ball. Then, place it on a baking sheet and make an indent with a measuring spoon.

6. Guava paste is the preferred topping for these cookies. I use a very small round biscuit cutter so the guava fits neatly inside the thumbprint. You can also use sprinkles (the other preferred topping in Puerto Rico), or maraschino cherries cut in half.

Expert Tips

• If the dough is too loose: Add a bit more milk. Small amounts go a long way. Once you add the milk, incorporate it and test it to see if it holds its shape.
• Keep the Dough Simple: Do not overmix the dough; mix just until combined. Overworking the dough can make the polvorones tough instead of tender.
• Store Properly: Once cooled, store polvorones in an airtight container at room temperature to keep them fresh. They can last up to a week and retain their melt-in-your-mouth texture. However, you may keep the cookies in the refrigerator for about a month. Just let them rest at room temperature for a few minutes to remove the chill from the fridge and soften the cookie.
• Dough Feels Too Soft to Handle: The problem could be overly softened or melted butter. Solution: Firm the dough in the fridge for 15-30 minutes. This will make it easier to roll and shape.
• Uneven Baking or Browning: Uneven oven temperature or cookie sizes can cause uneven browning. Solution: Use an oven thermometer to ensure accuracy and ensure all cookies are the same size. Rotate the baking sheet halfway through for even baking.

Recipe FAQs