Girl Meets Fire

menu icon
go to homepage
  • Recipes
  • Traditional Puerto Rican Classics
  • About me
  • Subscribe

subscribe
search icon
Homepage link
  • Recipes
  • Traditional Puerto Rican Classics
  • About me
  • Subscribe

×
Home » Recipes » Thanksgiving Favorites

The Easiest Sweet Potato Casserole You Could Ever Make

Portrait of a smiling woman chef in a home kitchen, used for the “About Me” section of Girl Meets Fire.
Modified: Apr 22, 2025 · Published: Nov 18, 2020 by Zoe Forestier Villegas · This post may contain affiliate links ·

Sharing is caring!

4 shares
  • Facebook
  • Email
  • Print
↓ Jump to Recipe
a bowl with sweet potato casserole
Sweet Potato Casserole

Sweet Potato is my favorite of all the spuds out there. This is quite funny because, as a child, I was not too fond of Batatas, the sweet potatoes we have in Puerto Rico. Although the batatas I was fed as a child were very different from the sweet potatoes I eat now, the American Sweet Potato has won my heart. I enjoy eating it fried, baked, boiled, and in the case of this recipe, as an almost souffle.

My first time eating sweet potatoes here in the United States, I was reluctant because I never quite liked their Puerto Rican cousin, so I didn't want to recreate the experience. But, courageously, I tasted this fantastic tuber and was won over. It was a baked sweet potato with all the candy-making goodness we could stuff it with, brown sugar, butter, and cinnamon. Maybe that was why I loved it; it was a personal size pie. I followed my baked sweet potato experience a few months later with a sweet potato casserole during Thanksgiving. Again, dressed in brown sugar, cinnamon, lots of butter, and this time toasted marshmallows and pecans. Amazing! "I'll have a little bit of dried-up turkey breast with a ton of this dessert pretending to be a side dish, please!" It was heaven! Since then, I have substituted potatoes with sweet potatoes whenever possible.

Being one with my sweet potato

Then, a couple of children and many pounds later, I decided to exercise and eat healthier. So I began to strip my sweet potato from all the candy-making toppings, and every time I started to eat it as close to what nature intended. I found many great qualities in this delicious tuber, so it was one of the few items I did not necessarily "ban" from my diet. It's a great source of vitamins C and A, antioxidants, anti-inflammatory, and many more. Click here to learn more about the health benefits of sweet potatoes.

Removing all the extra sugar was a bit scary. The last time I ate a stewed batata, the verdict was not favorable. I didn't want to ruin something I had come to enjoy so much. But I realized that the health benefits out weight the calorie-dense pleasures. so I baked the potato and tasted it without adding anything. My love rekindled. The sweet potato is sweet enough to stand on its own. It does not need extra sugar or lots of butter. The potato is delicious and has become how I have eaten it for the last few years. With or without a "diet."

Simplifying the Sweet Potato Casserole

I wanted to keep this casserole very basic and straightforward. You can add extra brown sugar, marshmallows, and pecans, but this works very well for me. I added one whole egg and milk and whipped the potatoes until fluffy. This gave the dish an airy texture and softness, similar to a souffle. I do not want to call this casserole a souffle because the measurements are not based on a souffle. The hope was to recreate the texture, which I did. The dish also has a delicately crisp top, which adds to the eating experience.

I will confess there is a small amount of brown sugar in this recipe, 1 tablespoon worth because I added the egg and milk. Let me explain; sometimes, we need to adjust the flavors that naturally occur in some ingredients, such as sweet potato. If I do not add sugar to the casserole, the milk and egg could neutralize the sweetness of the sweet potato. I am not saying the dish will not be sweet, but if we want the sweetness to be at the forefront, adding the brown sugar will enhance it without overpowering it.

This recipe goes well with . . .

  • Roasted Chicken
  • Ultimate Pretzel Stuffing
  • Puerto Rican Inspired Beef Stew

📖 Recipe

An image of sweet potato casserole

sweet potato casserole

Zoé Forestier
This recipe is easy to make and takes no time.  This fluffy baked sweet potatoes casserole with a delicate crisp crust.
No ratings yet
Print Recipe Pin Recipe
Course side dishes
Cuisine American
Servings 2 -4 servings

Ingredients
  

  • 2 large Sweet Potatoes peeled and cut into quarters
  • 2 tablespoons of butter
  • 1 tablespoon of brown sugar
  • 1 teaspoon of cinnamon
  • 1 egg
  • ¼ cup of milk I prefer heavy cream but didn't have it available.
  • a pinch of salt
Prevent your screen from going dark

Instructions
 

  • Preheat the oven to 350°.  Spray or brush oil inside casserole, set a side.
  • Boil the sweet potatoes until fork tender and soft.  About 20 minutes
  • Drain the potatoes and place them in a mixing bowl.  Option to mash the potatoes by hand with a hand masher, or you could whip the potatoes with an electric hand mixer or stand mixer.  
  • Add egg, heavy cream, cinnamon, and brown sugar.  Whip together until potatoes look fluffy.
  • Spoon potato mix into pregreased casserole.  Option to smooth potatoes flat or allow for peaks and valleys to form.
  • Place casserole in oven for about 20 minutes or until casserole reaches an internal temperature of 165°.  Remove from oven and serve
Scan the QR code to come back and tell me how it turned out.
Did you try this recipe?Please consider Leaving a Review, and if you loved it, give it a ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ rating too! It helps others find the recipe and tells Google it's worth a try. 😊

More Puerto Rican and Global Inspirations

  • Puerto Rican spice cake hojaldre añasqueño displayed as a spiral bundt and mini bundts dusted with powdered sugar, surrounded by flowers and a lace doily.
    Puerto Rican Spice Cake (Hojaldre Añasqueño)
  • Hand holding a peanut butter chocolate chip blondie broken in half to reveal a dense, chewy interior with visible chocolate chips, pecans, and peanut butter pieces, with a full tray of cut blondies on parchment paper in the background.
    Peanut Butter Blondies
  • Three stacked panetela de guayaba bars on a gray plate showing the guava paste layer, with a blue linen and striped wood cutting board in the background.
    Puerto Rican Guava Cakes (Panetela de Guayaba)
  • Overhead view of golden cauliflower yellow rice with bacon in braiser and white bowl with avocado slices on red plaid towel.
    Puerto Rican Cauliflower Yellow Rice

Sharing is caring!

4 shares
  • Facebook
  • Email
  • Print
Woman holding a wooden spoon and smiling in a kitchen with hanging utensils and a vase of flowers on the counter.

Hola! I'm Zoe. I love all things food and enjoy cooking. I created this site to reconnect with my Puerto Rican heritage while living in the United States. This is a great place to reconnect if you are floating in the diaspora. I would love to hear from you!

About Zoe →

Puerto Rican Christmas

  • Overhead view of Puerto Rican arroz con habichuelas (rice and beans) in glass bowl and two white bowls with avocado slices and peach peonies.
    Arroz con Habichuelas (Puerto Rican Rice with Beans)
  • Cooked gandules (pigeon peas) with split skins draining in wire mesh strainer over a stainless steel pot.
    Gandules (Pigeon Peas)
  • Arroz con gandules covered with banana leaves, served alongside carne frita on a holiday table.
    Arroz Con Gandules Recipe (Puerto Rican Rice and Pigeon Peas)
  • Collage of traditional Puerto Rican Christmas dishes including pernil, arroz con gandules, coquito, tembleque, arroz con dulce, and guineitos en escabeche, with a banner that reads “15 Essential Puerto Rican Christmas Recipes.”
    15 Puerto Rican Christmas Essentials (And a Few Delicious Extras)
  • Two glasses of cookies-and-cream coquito with crushed-cookie rims, surrounded by Oreo cookies and coquito ingredients, blurred in the background.
    Bacardi Gold Cookies and Cream Coquito
  • Top view of a molded pistachio tembleque garnished with shredded coconut and chopped pistachios on a white plate.
    Pistachio Tembleque
See more Christmas Recipes →

Popular Recipes

  • A plate of polvorones cookies with three semi-stacked cookies on top of the table resting in front of the plate.
    Puerto Rican Polvorones (Shortbread Cookies)
  • A blue and white dessert plate with a slice of bread pudding and caramel sauce on top of it.
    Budín de Pan (Puerto Rican Bread Pudding)
  • Close-up of a roasted chicken thigh served with guineos en escabeche, cherry tomatoes, and a side of macaroni salad partially visible.
    Puerto Rican Pollo Asado, Oven-Roasted Chicken
  • Close-up of shrimp and scallop stew over white rice, black beans, and fried sweet plantain, with a side of avocado and extra stew in the background.
    Quick Shrimp and Scallop Stew
  • A fork full of Pernil with a large serving bowl, avocados, dinner rolls, and small serving bowls with meat on the background.
    Instant Pot Puerto Rican Pernil (Pork Roast)
  • A hand holding a white bowl of funche topped with a dab of butter.
    Funche, Puerto Rican Grits

I’d love to hear from you! Did you try this recipe? Leave a review and rating below. Let’s connect on Instagram, and don’t forget to join my weekly email list for fresh new recipes.

Footer

Get new Puerto Rican recipes in your inbox every week!

Subscribe
↑ back to top

Explore

  • About Me
  • Firestarter Planner
  • Subscribe and eBook
  • Media Kit
  • Portfolio

About

  • Contact
  • Cookie Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of service
  • Accessibility Statement

Copyright © 2025 Girl Meets Fire LLC • Powered by Feast+ • This website contains affiliate links, which means that if you click on a product link, we may receive a commission in return. Girl Meets Fire LLC participates in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.

.

4 shares

Rate This Recipe

Your vote:




A rating is required
A name is required
An email is required