Girl Meets Fire

menu icon
go to homepage
  • Recipes
  • Traditional Puerto Rican Classics
  • About me
  • Subscribe
    • Email
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
  • subscribe
    search icon
    Homepage link
    • Recipes
    • Traditional Puerto Rican Classics
    • About me
    • Subscribe
    • Email
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
  • ×
    Home » Recipes » Vegan or Vegetarian

    Dec 3, 2020 · Modified: Apr 22, 2025 by Zoe Forestier Villegas · This post may contain affiliate links ·

    Smokey, Earthy, So Good for You Mushroom Soup

    ↓ Jump to Recipe

    This mushroom soup was so delicious, and it hit the right spot! Smoky, nutty flavors from the mushrooms combines with the creaminess of Manchego cheese and the sweetness of Marsala wine, rounded up this soup into a cup of earthy heaven!

    Wow, I got inspired! Do you want to know why? Because I was so excited about the mushrooms, I forgot the cream I needed to make this soup cream of mushroom soup; hence the title is just mushroom soup. But, the soup worked just fine without the heavy cream, and it was completely and totally delicious. I also wanted a piece of ciabatta toasted with blue cheese, and that didn't happen either, so I went with ciabatta and manchego. If you have not tried Manchego cheese, try it; you will love it.

    Mushrooms, mushrooms, everywhere

    I have been in a mushroom kick for the last month or so. I think it is the season. Autumn/Fall inspires harvest, warmth, and coziness, and for some reason, mushrooms do the same for me. A while back, my husband and I were shopping at Whole Foods. I will be honest, I do not shop at Whole Foods as much as I would like to, but for now it is a treat and the place I go to find something different. And that day was no exception. We found one pound container with exotic mushrooms. This pack had a combination of Trumpet Royales, Alba Clamshells, Brown Clamshells, Maitake Frondosa, Enoki, and Shitake.

    Honestly, I do not remember what we made with them the first time we came across them, but I was blown away by the mushrooms themselves. These mushrooms are grown very clean. Not one speck of dirt on them. They were very fresh and the taste was clean and fragrant. So, even though whatever I made was not memorable, working with the mushroom was, and I wanted to work with them again. So, I made my way back to Whole Food and found the mushrooms to make this delicious soup.

    When you don't have cream for your soup, make a broth

    So, my original plan was to make a cream of mushroom soup. I started the soup with that intend until I was about two steps away from adding the cream. I realized, that in my hyper focus of finding the mushrooms, I forgot to buy the cream, so now what? All I had was milk, hmm. I toyed with the idea of just making it a broth and adding beans and small diced onions and other vegetables to make it more like a broth. Only problem, I had added flour to the mushrooms to make a quick roux that would thicken my cream of mushroom. I still have milk . . .

    I decided to go halfway if that were possible. To make a broth like not quite creamy mushroom soup. Considering the hurdles, this soup came out perfect!

    "perchance to cream-ay, there's the rub"

    Soups are either a broth or a cream. There are bisques and chowders, but I personally classify those as cream based or broths. For example, Manhattan Clam Chowder is a broth based chowder, whereas New England Clam Chowder is a cream.

    Making a broth-based soup requires a liquid, be it water or a broth/stock, and flavorful aromatic vegetables and ingredients. All ingredients will be mostly visible when the soup is finished. Some potato based soups would turn murky due to the potato falling apart, but for the most part, all ingredients are easily identifiable, unless it gets blended as we would a tomato soup. Making a cream-based soup could require a roux to help with thickening of the soup and overall binding of the fats. These soups tend to be heavier, sometimes pureed and strained like a bisque.

    As for my mushroom soup, after I had sweated the mushrooms and added the shallots, I added flour. Again, until this point I thought I was going to make a cream soup. Like I had mentioned before, flour works as a binder and as a thickener, aka a roux. When we add flour to any recipe and use it as a Roux, the roux needs to be cooked, even if just slightly, to remove the flour taste and transform it to a nutty accent flavor. I will write a post on using roux soon, so stay tuned. The next logical steps would be to add a stock and follow with a cream. I added the vegetable broth and continued cooking the soup up to the point to add the cream.

    The not so creamy mushroom soup

    At this moment I decided to use milk, but not that much, just enough to give my soup a milky color. By no means would milk give my soup the creamy consistency, but I could still get the look I was looking for. I compensated my lack of cream with manchego cheese. You see, sometimes I look at ingredients at their most basic element. If I have had sour cream or a creme fraîche, this recipe would have been a cream of mushroom, but I did not. Manchego, although a hard cheese, it is softer than Parmesan cheese. It has also a nutty flavor and it is not stringy.

    The soup ended with a quasi creamy texture, but full of flavor. I had deglazed the pot with marsala wine right after the roux was cooked, and I seasoned the mushrooms with herb de provençe. The soup ended with a nice floral bouquet, delicate sweetness, and nutty earthiness. I had bought a nice ciabatta loaf, which I brushed with olive oil and fresh garlic and topped with more Manchego. I toasted the bread and used it as a tasty accompaniment to this delicious soup.

    This soup was super easy to make, the longest part of the soup was cooking the mushrooms. I hope you enjoy making this as much as I have. Please let me know how it turns out when you make it.

    You might also like these other recipes:
    • Shrimp and Butternut Squash Bisque
    • Chicken and Spicy Turkey White Chili

    📖 Recipe

    Mushroom Soup

    Mushroom Soup

    Zoé Forestier
    The smoky, nutty mushroom flavor combines with the creaminess of Manchego cheese and the sweetness of Marsala wine. A cup of earthy heaven!
    No ratings yet
    Print Recipe Pin Recipe
    Prep Time 10 minutes mins
    Cook Time 30 minutes mins
    Total Time 40 minutes mins
    Course Soup
    Cuisine American
    Servings 6 to 8 servings
    Calories 197 kcal

    Ingredients
      

    • two pounds of mushrooms. I used one pound of exotic mushrooms plus half a pound of button mushrooms, and half a pound of baby portabella mushrooms. All mushrooms small diced.
    • 2 tablespoon olive oil
    • one medium onion small diced
    • 3 garlic cloves minced
    • one teaspoon of herb de provençe
    • one ounce of flour
    • 32 ounces vegetable broth or chicken broth if you want more flavor
    • ¼ cup of marsala wine or any wine you prefer, red or white.
    • ¼ cup manchego cheese
    • salt and pepper to taste
    • fresh parsley for garnish
    • one pint of heavy cream if you would like to make this a cream of mushroom soup

    Instructions
     

    • Place a large stock pot on the stove at low to medium heat.  I used a 6 quart enameled cast iron dutch oven.   Do not over heat the pot, so that it will not smoke once you start cooking.
    • Small dice or rough chop the mushrooms.  Once the mushrooms are ready, make sure the pot is nice and hot by adding 1 tablespoon of olive oil, reserve the rest for later.  Olive oil will move fluidly on the pot but not smoke.  Add mushrooms.
    • Cook mushrooms, occasionally turning them with a spoon until the mushrooms have rendered all their liquid and reabsorbed it back.  You should get a nutty aroma from the mushrooms once they are cooked through.  Meanwhile dice the onions and garlic.
    • Once the mushrooms are ready, add the onions and garlic.  Add the other reserved tablespoon of olive oil if pan is too dry.  Cook onions and garlic until translucent and soft.
    • Add the remainder olive oil, if you did not use it with the onions and garlic, and add the one ounce of flour.  Cook the flour until flour turns golden and nutty aroma is prevelent.
    • With a wooden spoon, deglaze the bottom of the pot with the wine by gently rubbing the spoon on the bottom of the pan and lifting the brown bits off.
    • Switch the spoon to a whip (or whisk) and begin stirring the contents of the pot as you pour the broth in a steady stream .  This will eliminate any clumping of the flour.
    • Allow the soup to simmer for about 10 minutes.  Checking it occasionally.  You are looking for the thickness of the soup, and you do not want the contents to stick to the bottom either.  If the soup thickens too fast, add more stock or water to thin it.  If you desire, add cream in small increments to soup at this point to thin out the soup.
    • Taste the soup. If your soup taste like flour, cook the soup a bit longer.
    • To serve, laddle soup into bowls and grate manchego cheese on top. Sprinkle with fresh parsley and serve with a piece ciabbatta and machego toast.

    Nutrition

    Serving: 1gCalories: 197kcalCarbohydrates: 10.9gProtein: 6.1gFat: 15.5gSaturated Fat: 7.9gTrans Fat: 0.4gCholesterol: 35.7mgSodium: 621.5mgFiber: 1.7gSugar: 4.8g
    Tried this recipe?If you try this recipe, I’d love to see it! Tag me on Instagram @girlmeetsfire_puertoricancookn/ so I can check it out and share your creation!
    « The Easiest Sweet Potato Casserole You Could Ever Make
    How to Survive a Kitchen Renovation with Five Positive Survival Outlooks »
    Zoe standin in the kitchen smiling

    Hola! I'm Zoe. I love all things food and enjoy cooking. I created this site to reconnect with my Puerto Rican heritage while living in the United States. This is a great place to reconnect if you are floating in the diaspora. I would love to hear from you!

    About Zoe →

    Mother's Day Favorite Recipes

    • A slice of carrot cake on a plate with the rest of the cake and another slice in the background.
      Tropical Carrot Cake with Banana and Coconut

    • A bowl of ceviche is in the center, with two smaller bowls of ceviche and forks. A large bowl of tostones is at the top right, with small lemon wedges at the top left.
      Ceviche de Pescado y Camarones, Grouper and Shrimp Ceviche

    • Puerto Rican Bacalao a la Vizcaina

    • Caldo santo served in a bowl with tostones.
      Caldo Santo, Puerto Rican Coconut Seafood Soup

    • Bowl lined with paper towels and filled with fried mero chunks. A small bowl with cut lemons and a small bowl with tartar sauce.
      Grouper Bites, Chicharrones de Mero

    • A blue and white dessert plate with a slice of bread pudding and caramel sauce on top of it.
      Budín de Pan (Puerto Rican Bread Pudding)

    Popular Recipes

    • A plate of polvorones cookies with three semi-stacked cookies on top of the table resting in front of the plate.
      Puerto Rican Polvorones (Shortbread Cookies)

    • close-up-of-roasted-chicken-thighs-on-a-serving-platter
      Puerto Rican-Inspired Roasted Chicken Thighs

    • A blue and white dessert plate with a slice of bread pudding and caramel sauce on top of it.
      Budín de Pan (Puerto Rican Bread Pudding)

    • empanadas inside a paper towel lined bowl.
      Puerto Rican Empanadillas

    • an overhead view of a table set with two plates of arroz habichuelas and pan seared chicken thighs
      Puerto Rican Rice with Beans

    • pinchos served with potato salad and collard greens
      Pinchos de Cerdo, Puerto Rican Pork Kabobs

    I’d love to hear from you! Did you try this recipe? Leave a review and rating below. Let’s connect on Instagram, and don’t forget to join my weekly email list for fresh new recipes.

    Footer

    Subscribe for weekly updates!

    Subscribe
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookie Policy
    • Terms & Conditions
    • Accessibility Policy
    • ↑ back to top

    Copyright © 2025 Girl Meets Fire LLC • This website contains affiliate links, which means that if you click on a product link, we may receive a commission in return. Girl Meets Fire LLC participates in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.

    Rate This Recipe

    Your vote:




    A rating is required
    A name is required
    An email is required